Rabbi Ari
Kahn
Parashat Vayechi
5778
Who is First?
In the penultimate scene of Yaakov’s
life, Yosef is summoned to his ailing father’s sick bed, and he brings his two
sons with him. Previously, Yaakov had made Yosef promise to bury him in the
Land of Israel. As his final days slip away, Yaakov stands poised to bless Yosef’s
sons and grant them equal status among the tribes; Yaakov assigns Efraim and
Menashe a place among his own sons, rather than among his grandsons. Their status
as tribes effectively gives their father Yosef a “double portion,” the
birthright of the first-born son.
Were Yaakov’s parting interactions with
Yosef merely additional expressions of the favoritism Yaakov had displayed
toward Yosef in his youth? Why did Yaakov make his deathbed request for burial
in the ancestral tomb specifically of Yosef, and not all of his sons? While we
may say that it was Yosef, among all the sons, who had the power to fulfill
this request, surely there would have been no harm in addressing all the sons
as a group. And why were Yosef’s sons alone raised to a status far above all of
Yaakov’s other grandchildren? Why were they, and by extension their father
Yosef, favored with a double inheritance? Was this blessing a continuation of
the preferential treatment that had sparked the brothers’ jealousy and led them
to sell Yosef into slavery?
After announcing this double
inheritance, Yaakov asks that Efraim and Menashe approach him and receive his blessing,
but when they stand at their grandfather’s bedside, Yaakov appears to become
confused:
בראשית פרק מח: ח
וַיַּ֥רְא יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל אֶת־בְּנֵ֣י יוֹסֵ֑ף
וַיֹּ֖אמֶר מִי־אֵֽלֶּה:
And
Yisrael saw Yosef’s sons, and (Yisrael) said, “Who are these?” (Bereishit 48:8)
There are several possible explanations
for this confusion: In a subsequent verse, we are told that Yaakov (Yisrael)
had limited eyesight (Bereishit 48:10). Perhaps he simply could not see, or was
no longer able to see well enough to distinguish between them.[1] A second
possibility is that Yosef’s Egyptian-born sons looked strange and unfamiliar to
Yaakov, due to their regal dress and carriage and their foreign upbringing.[2] A third
possibility, raised by Rashi, is that Yaakov’s lack of clarity was not a
problem of eyesight but of clairvoyance: At that moment, Yaakov lost his
prophetic vision. He became frightened, not confused, and his question was not
aimed at clarifying the names or identities of his grandsons, but of their
worthiness, their spiritual identity:
רש"י, בראשית פרשת ויחי פרק מח פסוק ח
וירא ישראל את בני יוסף -בִּקֵּשׁ לְבָרֲכֵם, וְנִסְתַּלְּקָה שְׁכִינָה
מִמֶּנּוּ, לְפִי שֶׁעָתִיד יָרָבְעָם וְאַחְאָב לָצֵאת מֵאֶפְרַיִם וְיֵהוּא וּבָנָיו
מִמְּנַשֶּׁה: ויאמר מי אלה- מֵהֵיכָן יָצְאוּ אֵלּוּ, שֶׁאֵינָן
רְאוּיִן לִבְרָכָה:
And
Yisrael saw Yosef’s sons, —
he wished to bless them but the Divine Presence departed from him because he
saw that from Efraim would be born the wicked kings Yerovam and Ahav, and from
Menasheh Yehu and his sons (Midrash Tanchuma, Vayechi 6). (Yisrael) asked,
“Who are these?” — from where did these come, who are unfit for blessing?
According to Rashi, there was evil
lurking in the future, something that Yaakov had never seen before, and this
caused him to lose his ruach hakodesh and to question whether these sons
of Yosef were in fact deserving of the blessing he was about to bestow on them. Yaakov saw evil
in the future: Yerovam, Ahav, and Yehu, three wicked kings of Israel, were
descendants of Yosef.
Yaakov could not
imagine that Yosef would spawn such offspring. He had never seen any negative
sides to his favorite son’s personality. Yosef was the golden child, Yaakov’s
favorite.[3] From a very
young age, Yaakov knew that Yosef was destined for greatness. He dressed Yosef in
the special, regal clothes, making it plain to anyone who saw him that Yosef
was the anointed one.
For the most part,
Yosef’s dreams were consonant with Yaakov’s expectations and aspirations: Yosef,
the son of his beloved wife Rachel, was not like his other children, and his
dreams of economic and political dominance simply echoed what Yaakov had
already intuited: Yosef was born to lead. Yaakov’s other children, however, did
not take kindly to the predictions of their own subservience. Their jealousy
led to hatred, which nearly led to murder, ultimately resulted in the sale of
Yosef.
From the moment,
he retells his dreams to his father and brothers, Yosef’s dreams remain just
below the surface of the narrative for the remainder of Bereishit. Thus, the
brothers refer to what they believe to be Yosef’s delusions of grandeur as they
plot to dispose of him:
בראשית פרק לז:
יט-כ
וַיֹּאמְר֖וּ אִ֣ישׁ אֶל־אָחִ֑יו הִנֵּ֗ה
בַּ֛עַל הַחֲלֹמ֥וֹת הַלָּזֶ֖ה בָּֽא: וְעַתָּ֣ה׀ לְכ֣וּ וְנַֽהַרְגֵ֗הוּ וְנַשְׁלִכֵ֙הוּ֙ בְּאַחַ֣ד הַבֹּר֔וֹת
וְאָמַ֕רְנוּ חַיָּ֥ה רָעָ֖ה אֲכָלָ֑תְהוּ וְנִרְאֶ֕ה מַה־יִּהְי֖וּ חֲלֹמֹתָֽיו:
“Then one said to the other, “Here comes that dreamer.
Come now, let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits; and we can say,
‘A savage beast devoured him;’ then we shall see what becomes of his dreams!”
(Bereishit 37:19-20)
Many years later, when the brothers
come searching for food, they do not imagine that Yosef’s dreams of power and
economic superiority were not delusions but prophecies. They bow to Yosef, as
his dream predicted they would; they beg him for food, as his dreams predicted
they would. For Yosef, the dreams are a real and powerful element of his
consciousness; he remembers the dreams from the moment his brothers re-enter
his life:
בראשית פרק מב: ו-ט
וְיוֹסֵ֗ף ה֚וּא הַשַּׁלִּ֣יט עַל־הָאָ֔רֶץ
ה֥וּא הַמַּשְׁבִּ֖יר לְכָל־עַ֣ם הָאָ֑רֶץ וַיָּבֹ֙אוּ֙ אֲחֵ֣י יוֹסֵ֔ף
וַיִּשְׁתַּֽחֲווּ־ל֥וֹ אַפַּ֖יִם אָֽרְצָה: וַיַּ֥רְא יוֹסֵ֛ף אֶת־אֶחָ֖יו וַיַּכִּרֵ֑ם וַיִּתְנַכֵּ֨ר אֲלֵיהֶ֜ם
וַיְדַבֵּ֧ר אִתָּ֣ם קָשׁ֗וֹת וַיֹּ֤אמֶר אֲלֵהֶם֙ מֵאַ֣יִן בָּאתֶ֔ם
וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ מֵאֶ֥רֶץ כְּנַ֖עַן לִשְׁבָּר־אֹֽכֶל: וַיַּכֵּ֥ר יוֹסֵ֖ף אֶת־אֶחָ֑יו וְהֵ֖ם לֹ֥א הִכִּרֻֽהוּ: וַיִּזְכֹּ֣ר יוֹסֵ֔ף אֵ֚ת הַחֲלֹמ֔וֹת אֲשֶׁ֥ר חָלַ֖ם לָהֶ֑ם
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר אֲלֵהֶם֙ מְרַגְּלִ֣ים אַתֶּ֔ם לִרְא֛וֹת אֶת־עֶרְוַ֥ת הָאָ֖רֶץ
בָּאתֶֽם:
Now Yosef was the vizier of the land; it was he who dispensed rations to all
the people of the land. And Yosef’s brothers came and bowed low to him, with
their faces to the ground. When Yosef saw his brothers, he recognized them; but he
acted like a stranger toward them and spoke harshly to them. He asked them,
“Where do you come from?” And they said, “From the land of Canaan, to procure
food.” For though Yosef recognized his brothers, they did not
recognize him. Recalling the dreams that he had dreamed about
them, Yosef said to them, “You are spies, you have come to
see the land in its nakedness.” (Bereishit 42:6-9)
In an exchange dripping with delicious
irony, the brothers bow to the powerful supplier of food, yet they do not know
that is their long-lost, nearly- murdered brother, whom they had kidnapped and
sold. Yosef alone remembers the dreams, and the dreams have come true.[4] Yet it
seems almost like the famous philosophical conundrum: If a tree falls in the
forest and no one hears… Can we say that the brothers have truly bowed to Yosef
if they do not know who he is? Must they actually experience and internalize
their subservience to their brother, or acknowledge Yosef’s greatness, for the
dreams to be fulfilled?
Setting this question aside for the
moment, we might remind ourselves that the dreams are a subtext, as we have
noted, and not the central theme of the tension that builds in the course of
their encounter. The larger issue seems to be that Yosef is gauging his
brothers’ morality: Have they remained the same jealous, devious bunch? Is his
younger brother Binyamin safe? Is his father still alive? Have they been
transformed by the years of separation? Do they regret how they treated him? Is
there still a chance for reconciliation?
From the moment Yosef heard Pharaoh’s dreams,
he knew that his brothers would arrive - sooner rather than later. He also knew
that as soon as they arrived, they would bow – but there was much more that he
did not know. And so, when they do arrive, and when they bow to him, oblivious
to his true identity, Yosef watches and listens carefully. He puts them through
a series of rigorous tests in order to answer his own questions, and in the end
the brothers – particularly Yehuda - pass the test: Yehuda is prepared to
sacrifice himself and become a slave so that Binyamin can be free. Yosef, who has
first-hand insight as to the physical and emotional price this entails, is moved;
Yehuda’s extraordinary gesture allows Yosef to bring the charade to an end, and
to reveal his identity.
The real question is, what’s next? Essentially,
only Yosef can answer this question; after all, he holds all the cards. Yosef
is in charge – not only of Egypt, and of the fate of his brothers, but also of
the type of reconciliation, if any, they can expect, and the new rules of
engagement.
There are three obvious possibilities:
First: Yosef punishes his brothers. He recalls
everything he went through because of them – the humiliation, slavery, mortal
danger, and estrangement from his beloved father. As we have already noted,[5] the
former apprentice to the chief executioner of Egypt surely had the knowledge,
power and means to subject his brothers to unimaginable pain. Alternatively,
sentencing them to live out their lives as slaves might have been the just and
equitable punishment for their perfidy. Nonetheless, Yosef has no thoughts of
revenge.
Second: Yosef wipes the slate clean,
expunges the past, and starts from scratch, building a new relationship with
his now-transformed brothers, on equal footing with them at last. This approach
would arguably go a long way toward excising the cancerous feelings of jealousy
and hatred which are in danger of growing even stronger than they had been,
festering and metastasizing on the fertile ground of Yosef’s success.
Yosef chooses a third path: While he
does not take revenge, he does not seek equality. An analysis of the language
of the verses that describe their relationship reveals his plan, his thoughts -
and his dreams for the future.
בראשית פרק מה:ג
וַיֹּ֨אמֶר יוֹסֵ֤ף אֶל־אֶחָיו֙ אֲנִ֣י יוֹסֵ֔ף הַע֥וֹד אָבִ֖י
חָ֑י וְלֹֽא־יָכְל֤וּ אֶחָיו֙ לַעֲנ֣וֹת אֹת֔וֹ כִּ֥י נִבְהֲל֖וּ מִפָּנָֽיו:
Yosef said to his brothers, “I am Yosef. Is my father
still alive?” But his brothers could not answer him, so shaken were they on
account of him. (Bereishit 45:3)
Yosef speaks,
and the text stresses that it is to his brothers that he addresses himself.
This very loaded term gives us hope for fraternity and brotherhood, but that
hope quickly disappears: Yosef asks, “Is my father still alive?” Had he
wished for reconciliation, he would surely have included them: “Is our
father still alive?”
The
bothers are in shock; they are speechless. Yosef tries, once again, to engage
them. There are many things he can say to assure them of his identity, and he
urges them to come close - but then he chooses to remind them of the most
painful parts of their relationship, using words that must have cut like the
jagged edge of a knife:
בראשית פרק מה:ד
וַיֹּ֨אמֶר יוֹסֵ֧ף אֶל־אֶחָ֛יו גְּשׁוּ־נָ֥א אֵלַ֖י וַיִּגָּ֑שׁוּ
וַיֹּ֗אמֶר אֲנִי֙ יוֹסֵ֣ף אֲחִיכֶ֔ם אֲשֶׁר־מְכַרְתֶּ֥ם אֹתִ֖י
מִצְרָֽיְמָה:
Then Yosef said to his brothers, “Please, come forward to
me.” And when they came forward, he said, “I am your brother Yosef, whom you
sold into Egypt. (Bereishit 45:4)
Yosef assures
them he is, in fact, their brother, that he has returned from the grave they
dug for him in their minds; he is the same Yosef they had sold all those years
ago. Once again, Yosef creates a moment of closeness - “I am Yosef your brother”
- but quickly follows with a crushing dose of blunt truth – “whom you sold into
[slavery in] Egypt.” Had he sought reconciliation, there were so many other
words he could have used to convince them of his identity. But Yosef continues,
and a deviousness emerges:
בראשית פרק מה:ה-ז
וְעַתָּ֣ה׀ אַל־תֵּעָ֣צְב֗וּ
וְאַל־יִ֙חַר֙ בְּעֵ֣ינֵיכֶ֔ם כִּֽי־מְכַרְתֶּ֥ם אֹתִ֖י הֵ֑נָּה כִּ֣י לְמִֽחְיָ֔ה
שְׁלָחַ֥נִי אֱלֹהִ֖ים לִפְנֵיכֶֽם: כִּי־זֶ֛ה שְׁנָתַ֥יִם הָרָעָ֖ב בְּקֶ֣רֶב הָאָ֑רֶץ וְעוֹד֙ חָמֵ֣שׁ שָׁנִ֔ים
אֲשֶׁ֥ר אֵין־חָרִ֖ישׁ וְקָצִֽיר: וַיִּשְׁלָחֵ֤נִי אֱלֹהִים֙ לִפְנֵיכֶ֔ם לָשׂ֥וּם לָכֶ֛ם שְׁאֵרִ֖ית
בָּאָ֑רֶץ וּלְהַחֲי֣וֹת לָכֶ֔ם לִפְלֵיטָ֖ה גְּדֹלָֽה: וְעַתָּ֗ה לֹֽא־אַתֶּ֞ם
שְׁלַחְתֶּ֤ם אֹתִי֙ הֵ֔נָּה כִּ֖י הָאֱלֹהִ֑ים וַיְשִׂימֵ֨נִֽי לְאָ֜ב לְפַרְעֹ֗ה
וּלְאָדוֹן֙ לְכָל־בֵּית֔וֹ וּמֹשֵׁ֖ל בְּכָל־אֶ֥רֶץ מִצְרָֽיִם:
Now, do not be distressed or reproach yourselves because you
sold me to this place; it was to save life that God sent me ahead of you. It is
now two years that there has been famine in the land, and there are still five
years to come in which there shall be no yield from tilling. God has sent me
ahead of you to ensure your survival on earth, and to save your lives in an
extraordinary deliverance. So, it was not you who sent me here, but God; and He
has made me a father to Pharaoh, lord of all his household, and ruler over the
whole land of Egypt. (Bereishit 45:5-8)
With an
artfully crafted explanation that displays his brilliance, Yosef praises God
for bringing him to Egypt and to his lofty position, and at the same time
exonerates his brothers, removing them completely from the narrative. On the
one hand, he explains that God’s master-plan brought him to Egypt and secured
him in a position of unimaginable power. Many lives, including their own, will
be saved. But lest they receive any credit, even incidental credit, for
anything good that results from Yosef rise to power, he stresses that this was
all the work of God. The sub-text is extraordinary: Yosef knew, from the start,
that he would achieve greatness. He tried to tell them, to share his worldview,
but they scorned him and scoffed at his predictions. They were so far off the
mark, he tells them, that they cannot take any credit whatsoever for the
fortuitous outcome, because they were oblivious to the truth all along. They
were nothing more than pawns, marionettes whose strings were pulled by the
master of the Divine drama that catapulted Yosef to the top. He alone, he tells
them in his just-subtle enough speech, has always been the star of the show. He
has always been the main character; they are merely “extras” in a cast of
thousands. Yosef gives God all the credit; he wants them to understand that God
is on his side.
Yosef’s
speech is stunning. These are not the words of a man seeking peace, love,
fraternity, or reconciliation. The speech is self-serving from start to finish,
bordering on narcissistic, and these same tropes are echoed in his instructions
for breaking the news to his father that he is alive:
בראשית פרק מה:ט-יג
מַהֲרוּ֘ וַעֲל֣וּ
אֶל־אָבִי֒ וַאֲמַרְתֶּ֣ם אֵלָ֗יו כֹּ֤ה אָמַר֙ בִּנְךָ֣ יוֹסֵ֔ף
שָׂמַ֧נִי אֱלֹהִ֛ים לְאָד֖וֹן לְכָל־מִצְרָ֑יִם רְדָ֥ה אֵלַ֖י אַֽל־תַּעֲמֹֽד:
וְיָשַׁבְתָּ֣ בְאֶֽרֶץ־גֹּ֗שֶׁן וְהָיִ֤יתָ קָרוֹב֙ אֵלַ֔י אַתָּ֕ה וּבָנֶ֖יךָ
וּבְנֵ֣י בָנֶ֑יךָ וְצֹאנְךָ֥ וּבְקָרְךָ֖ וְכָל־אֲשֶׁר־לָֽךְ: וְכִלְכַּלְתִּ֤י
אֹֽתְךָ֙ שָׁ֔ם כִּי־ע֛וֹד חָמֵ֥שׁ שָׁנִ֖ים רָעָ֑ב פֶּן־תִּוָּרֵ֛שׁ אַתָּ֥ה
וּבֵֽיתְךָ֖ וְכָל־אֲשֶׁר־לָֽךְ: וְהִנֵּ֤ה עֵֽינֵיכֶם֙ רֹא֔וֹת וְעֵינֵ֖י אָחִ֣י בִנְיָמִ֑ין
כִּי־פִ֖י הַֽמְדַבֵּ֥ר אֲלֵיכֶֽם: וְהִגַּדְתֶּ֣ם לְאָבִ֗י אֶת־כָּל־כְּבוֹדִי֙
בְּמִצְרַ֔יִם וְאֵ֖ת כָּל־אֲשֶׁ֣ר רְאִיתֶ֑ם וּמִֽהַרְתֶּ֛ם וְהוֹרַדְתֶּ֥ם אֶת־אָבִ֖י
הֵֽנָּה:
“Now, hurry back to my father and say to him: ‘Thus says your
son Yosef, ‘God has made me lord of all Egypt; come down to me without delay. You
will dwell in the region of Goshen, where you will be near me—you and your
children and your grandchildren, your flocks and herds, and all that is yours. There
I will provide for you; —for there are yet five years of famine to come—that
you and your household and all that is yours may not suffer want.’ You can see
for yourselves, and my brother Binyamin for himself, that it is indeed I who am
speaking to you. And you must tell my father everything about my high station
in Egypt and all that you have seen; and bring my father here with all speed.”
(Bereishit 45:9-13)
Yosef
wants his father to know that God has placed him as leader and lord over Egypt;
again, he refers to his father, not their (collective) father, and
his own personal glory, power, and honor. The benevolent Yosef lets it
be known that he will care for them all, provide them with food, homes, and all
their other needs - yet his benevolence comes at a price. He infantilizes his
brothers by caring for them, creating total dependence on his good graces
rather than employing them in meaningful, productive positions.[6] His benevolence
feeds and strengthens his dreams; the reality he creates surpasses even his
dreams.
What do
the brothers hear? How do they interpret his kindness? Apparently, they see what
they had always seen: Yosef’s narcissism. Even when Yosef embraces them and cries
on the shoulders of each of his brothers, only Binyamin reciprocates; the other
brothers stand stone cold, either in shock or in disgust. They are convinced
that they had been right about Yosef from the start.
בראשית פרק מה:יד-טו
וַיִּפֹּ֛ל עַל־צַוְּארֵ֥י בִנְיָמִֽן־אָחִ֖יו וַיֵּ֑בְךְּ וּבִנְיָמִ֔ן
בָּכָ֖ה עַל־צַוָּארָֽיו: וַיְנַשֵּׁ֥ק לְכָל־אֶחָ֖יו וַיֵּ֣בְךְּ עֲלֵהֶ֑ם
וְאַ֣חֲרֵי כֵ֔ן דִּבְּר֥וּ אֶחָ֖יו אִתּֽוֹ:
With that he embraced his brother Binyamin around the neck
and wept, and Binyamin wept on his neck. He kissed all his brothers and wept
upon them; only then were his brothers able to talk to him. (Bereishit
45:14-15)
Yosef
shares with his brothers a state secret, there would be five more years of
drought and hunger. Yosef prides himself into seeing into the future, and
shares with his brothers, they should tell Yaakov who should hurry down.
As the
brothers leave, Yosef shows favoritism to his full brother Binyamin, mistakes
from the past will not be corrected, they will be institutionalized, for Yosef
the story has a happy ending. He has been vindicated, and now all his brothers
know it. The tree which fell in the forest could now be heard loud and clear.
בראשית פרק מה: כב-כד
לְכֻלָּ֥ם נָתַ֛ן לָאִ֖ישׁ חֲלִפ֣וֹת שְׂמָלֹ֑ת וּלְבִנְיָמִ֤ן
נָתַן֙ שְׁלֹ֣שׁ מֵא֣וֹת כֶּ֔סֶף וְחָמֵ֖שׁ חֲלִפֹ֥ת שְׂמָלֹֽת: וּלְאָבִ֞יו
שָׁלַ֤ח כְּזֹאת֙ עֲשָׂרָ֣ה חֲמֹרִ֔ים נֹשְׂאִ֖ים מִטּ֣וּב מִצְרָ֑יִם וְעֶ֣שֶׂר אֲתֹנֹ֡ת
נֹֽ֠שְׂאֹת בָּ֣ר וָלֶ֧חֶם וּמָז֛וֹן לְאָבִ֖יו לַדָּֽרֶךְ: וַיְשַׁלַּ֥ח אֶת־אֶחָ֖יו
וַיֵּלֵ֑כוּ וַיֹּ֣אמֶר אֲלֵהֶ֔ם אַֽל־תִּרְגְּז֖וּ בַּדָּֽרֶךְ:
To each of them, moreover, he gave a change of clothing; but
to Binyamin he gave three hundred pieces of silver and five changes of
clothing. And to his father he sent the following: ten donkeys laden with the
best things of Egypt, and ten she-asses laden with grain, bread, and provisions
for his father on the journey. As he sent his brothers off on their way, he
told them, “Do not be quarrelsome on the way.” (Bereishit 45:22-24)
Upon
returning to Yaakov, the brothers share the news in more subdued tones: Yosef
is alive, and he rules over Egypt. After overcoming his initial disbelief, Yaakov
comes back to life, and his spirit of prophecy returns.
בראשית פרק מה: כה-כח
וַֽיַּעֲל֖וּ מִמִּצְרָ֑יִם וַיָּבֹ֙אוּ֙ אֶ֣רֶץ
כְּנַ֔עַן אֶֽל־יַעֲקֹ֖ב אֲבִיהֶֽם: וַיַּגִּ֨דוּ ל֜וֹ לֵאמֹ֗ר ע֚וֹד
יוֹסֵ֣ף חַ֔י וְכִֽי־ה֥וּא מֹשֵׁ֖ל בְּכָל־אֶ֣רֶץ מִצְרָ֑יִם וַיָּ֣פָג לִבּ֔וֹ
כִּ֥י לֹא־הֶאֱמִ֖ין לָהֶֽם: וַיְדַבְּר֣וּ אֵלָ֗יו אֵ֣ת כָּל־דִּבְרֵ֤י יוֹסֵף֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר
דִּבֶּ֣ר אֲלֵהֶ֔ם וַיַּרְא֙ אֶת־הָ֣עֲגָל֔וֹת אֲשֶׁר־שָׁלַ֥ח יוֹסֵ֖ף לָשֵׂ֣את אֹת֑וֹ
וַתְּחִ֕י ר֖וּחַ יַעֲקֹ֥ב אֲבִיהֶֽם: וַיֹּ֙אמֶר֙ יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל רַ֛ב עוֹד־יוֹסֵ֥ף
בְּנִ֖י חָ֑י אֵֽלְכָ֥ה וְאֶרְאֶ֖נּוּ בְּטֶ֥רֶם אָמֽוּת:
They went up from Egypt and came to their father Yaakov in
the land of Canaan. And they told him, “Yosef is still alive, and he is ruler
over the whole land of Egypt.” His heart went numb, for he did not believe
them. But when they recounted all that Yosef had said to them, and when he saw
the wagons that Yosef had sent to transport him, the spirit of their father Yaakov
was revived. “Enough!” said Yisrael. “My son Yosef is still alive! I must go
and see him before I die.” (Bereishit 45:25-28)
While
Yosef had his dreams which indeed came true, Yaakov armed with prophecy, sees further
into the future:
בראשית פרק מו,
א-ד
וַיִּסַּ֤ע יִשְׂרָאֵל֙
וְכָל־אֲשֶׁר־ל֔וֹ וַיָּבֹ֖א בְּאֵ֣רָה שָּׁ֑בַע וַיִּזְבַּ֣ח זְבָחִ֔ים לֵאלֹהֵ֖י
אָבִ֥יו יִצְחָֽק: וַיֹּ֨אמֶר אֱלֹהִ֤ים׀ לְיִשְׂרָאֵל֙ בְּמַרְאֹ֣ת הַלַּ֔יְלָה
וַיֹּ֖אמֶר יַעֲקֹ֣ב׀ יַעֲקֹ֑ב וַיֹּ֖אמֶר הִנֵּֽנִי: וַיֹּ֕אמֶר אָנֹכִ֥י הָאֵ֖ל
אֱלֹהֵ֣י אָבִ֑יךָ אַל־תִּירָא֙ מֵרְדָ֣ה מִצְרַ֔יְמָה כִּֽי־לְג֥וֹי גָּד֖וֹל אֲשִֽׂימְךָ֥
שָֽׁם: אָנֹכִ֗י אֵרֵ֤ד עִמְּךָ֙ מִצְרַ֔יְמָה וְאָנֹכִ֖י אַֽעַלְךָ֣ גַם־עָלֹ֑ה וְיוֹסֵ֕ף
יָשִׁ֥ית יָד֖וֹ עַל־עֵינֶֽיךָ:
So Yisrael set out with all that was his, and he came to
Beer Sheva, where he offered sacrifices to the God of his father Yitzchak. God
called to Yisrael in a vision by night: “Yaakov! Yaakov!” He answered, “I am here.”
And He said, “I am God, the God of your father. Fear not to go down to Egypt,
for I will make you there into a great nation. I Myself will go down
with you to Egypt, and I Myself will also bring you back; and Yosef’s hand
shall close your eyes.” (Bereishit 46:1-4)
Yaakov
has been told they will become a numerous people during this sojourn; clearly,
this vision extends well beyond five years into the future that Yosef is able
to see. Yaakov understands that this
exile will continue for hundreds of years. He knows that the fruition of the
covenant God made with Avraham has begun; slavery and affliction will soon
follow. Yosef can amuse himself with his power, but Yaakov knows it is
temporary. Although Yaakov lives out his years in Egypt, reunited with the son
he always loved, but he is nonetheless preoccupied with the future.
Now, we
return to the deathbed scene. Yaakov is taken aback; he sees something coming,
something evil that emerges from Yosef, something he had never seen before: Yosef’s
descendants will be self-centered, narcissistic leaders who will lead the
nation astray. In shock, Yaakov asks, “Who are these people?”[7] - even though the people standing at his
bedside are Yosef’s sons Efraim and Menashe, whom we have every reason to believe
were fine, upstanding young men. Yaakov feels his prophetic vision slipping
away in the face of something sinister, and he is shocked and alarmed: This is
a side of Yosef he had never seen – but perhaps should have seen. Our sages point
out Yosef’s immaturity and narcissism from a very early stage in his life story:
בראשית פרק לז, ב
אֵ֣לֶּה׀ תֹּלְד֣וֹת יַעֲקֹ֗ב יוֹסֵ֞ף
בֶּן־שְׁבַֽע־עֶשְׂרֵ֤ה שָׁנָה֙ הָיָ֨ה רֹעֶ֤ה אֶת־אֶחָיו֙ בַּצֹּ֔אן וְה֣וּא נַ֗עַר
אֶת־בְּנֵ֥י בִלְהָ֛ה וְאֶת־בְּנֵ֥י זִלְפָּ֖ה נְשֵׁ֣י אָבִ֑יו וַיָּבֵ֥א יוֹסֵ֛ף
אֶת־דִּבָּתָ֥ם רָעָ֖ה אֶל־אֲבִיהֶֽם:
This is the line of Yaakov: At seventeen years of age,
Yosef tended the flocks with his brothers, and he was a lad (naar) to
the sons of his father’s wives Bilhah and Zilpah. And Yosef brought bad reports
of them to their father. (Bereishit 37:2)
רש"י בראשית פרק לז:ב
וְהוּא נַעַר - שֶׁהָיָה עוֹשֶׂה מַעֲשֵׂה
נַעֲרוּת, מְתַקֵּן בְּשַׂעֲרוֹ, מְמַשְׁמֵשׁ בְּעֵינָיו, כְּדֵי שֶׁיִּהְיֶה נִרְאֶה יָפֶה:
…and he was a lad (naar) — His actions were
childish: he dressed his hair, he touched up his eyes so that he should appear
good-looking. (Rashi, Bereishit 37:2, based on Bereishit Rabbah
84:7)
בראשית פרק לט: ו
וַיַּעֲזֹ֣ב כָּל־אֲשֶׁר־לוֹ֘ בְּיַד־יוֹסֵף֒
וְלֹא־יָדַ֤ע אִתּוֹ֙ מְא֔וּמָה כִּ֥י אִם־הַלֶּ֖חֶם אֲשֶׁר־ה֣וּא אוֹכֵ֑ל
וַיְהִ֣י יוֹסֵ֔ף יְפֵה־תֹ֖אַר וִיפֵ֥ה מַרְאֶֽה:
He left all that he had in
Yosef’s hands and, with him there, he paid attention to nothing save the food
that he ate. Now Yosef was well built and handsome. (Bereishit
39:6)
רש"י בראשית פרק לט:ו
וַיְהִי יוֹסֵף יְפֵה־תֹאַר וִיפֵה מַרְאֶה - כֵּיוָן שֶׁרָאָה עַצְמוֹ מוֹשֵׁל, הִתְחִיל אוֹכֵל וְשׁוֹתֶה וּמְסַלְסֵל בְּשַֹעֲרוֹ
אָמַר הַקָּבָּ"ה אָבִיךָ מִתְאַבֵּל, וְאַתָּה מְסַלְסֵל בִּשְֹעָרֶךָ, אֲנִי
מְגָרֶה בְךָ אֶת הַדּוֹב! מִיָּד…:
And Yosef was well built and handsome — As soon as he saw that he was ruler (in the
house) he began to eat and drink and curl his hair. The Holy One, blessed be
He, said to him, “Your father is mourning and you curl your hair! I will let a
bear loose against you” (Midrash Tanchuma, Vayeshev 8). Immediately… (Rashi Bereishit 39:6)
The Rabbis see something that evades
Yaakov’s detection, something self-absorbed in Yosef’s personality. Yosef is
certain that he is destined to lead, and he is attracted to the trappings of leadership.
In Yosef’s descendants, specifically
the kings cited above, this dysfunction morphs into a pathological spiritual
sickness. Yerovam thinks it wise to repeat the greatest offense committed by
his ancestors, and builds not one but two golden calves. He stations guards at
the border crossings to prevent Jews from making pilgrimages to Jerusalem. Yerovam
is willing to lead an entire generation astray just to assure his exalted
position.
In one of the most extreme expressions
of this illness, the rabbis tell of a conversation between God and Yerovam:
תלמוד בבלי מסכת סנהדרין דף קב עמוד א
אַחַר הַדָּבָר הַזֶּה לֹא שָׁב יָרָבְעָם מִדַּרְכּוֹ הָרָעָה [מלכים א:יג] מַאי ,אַחַר'? אָמַר רַבִּי אַבָּא, אַחַר שֶׁתְּפָשׂוֹ הַקָּדוֹשׁ בָּרוּךְ הוּא לְיָרָבְעָם בְּבִגְדוֹ, וְאָמַר לוֹ, חֲזֹר בְּךָ, וַאֲנִי וְאַתָּה וּבֶן יִשַׁי נְטַיֵּל בְּגַן עֵדֶן. אָמַר לוֹ, מִי בָּרֹאשׁ? אָמַר לוֹ, בֶּן יִשַׁי בָּרֹאשׁ. אִי הָכִי - לָא בָּעִינָא:
“And after this matter, Yerovam did not repent from his evil ways” (I Kings 13:33). What does “after” refer to? Rabbi Abba
says: After the Holy One, Blessed be He, grabbed Yerovam by his garment, and said to him: Repent, and you and I and the son of Yishai will stroll together in the Garden of Eden. (Yerovam) said to Him: Who will be in the lead? (God) said to (Yerovam): The son of Yishai will be in the lead. (Yerovam) said: If so, I am not interested. (Talmud Bavli Sanhedrin 102a)
This passage expresses the almost
unimaginable, unmitigated gall of Yerovam: God “grabbed Yerovam by his garment” - a
phrase that directly links Yerovam with his forefather Yosef. He is offered a stroll with God and the
Messiah in the Garden of Eden, the most exclusive journey (pilgrimage?) in the
most exclusive, exalted company – but his first question is, “Who is first?”
Who will take the lead? Can Yerovam have imagined that God Himself would take a
back seat to a mortal king? God seems to go along, hoping to teach Yerovam a
lesson in humility, and does not put Himself in the lead, but when Yerovam
hears that he himself will not be the star of the show – he rejects God!
This is the side of Yosef the brothers
always saw. They sensed that his first, perhaps his only concern, was
self-aggrandizement. And yet, Yosef’s clothes were left behind when he
escaped from the clutches of Mrs. Potifar, while Yerovam’s garments are torn
from him as he escapes the grasp of God - and there, in a nutshell, lies the
complexity of Yosef. Yosef managed to suppress the negative aspects of his
personality; Yerovam did not. But the brothers could not see this. When they looked at
Yosef, they saw only the vainglorious, self-righteous, pretentious side of his
personality. While Yaakov was blind to Yosef’s darker side, the
brothers were blind to the positive side. They knew nothing about Yosef’s
spiritual struggles and victories. They knew nothing of the temptations he
faced and overcame. They did not hear him speak about God to all those around
him, even at his own peril. They did not know that he took no personal credit
for interpreting Pharaoh’s dreams and saving Egypt. They did not know how truly
great he was. And so, even when he delivers a speech and makes a commitment to
set aside the past and care for them and their families, they hear the “B side”
of the record: Yosef “forgives” them “for nothing;” he
intimates that they were unimportant details in the story. Once again, they see
and the parts of his personality they had always hated. Even worse, they were
afraid of him
בראשית פרק נ: יד-כא
וַיָּ֨שָׁב יוֹסֵ֤ף מִצְרַ֙יְמָה֙ ה֣וּא וְאֶחָ֔יו וְכָל־הָעֹלִ֥ים אִתּ֖וֹ לִקְבֹּ֣ר אֶת־אָבִ֑יו אַחֲרֵ֖י קָבְר֥וֹ אֶת־אָבִֽיו: וַיִּרְא֤וּ אֲחֵֽי־יוֹסֵף֙ כִּי־מֵ֣ת אֲבִיהֶ֔ם וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ ל֥וּ יִשְׂטְמֵ֖נוּ יוֹסֵ֑ף וְהָשֵׁ֤ב יָשִׁיב֙ לָ֔נוּ אֵ֚ת כָּל־הָ֣רָעָ֔ה אֲשֶׁ֥ר גָּמַ֖לְנוּ אֹתֽוֹ:
(טז)
וַיְצַוּ֕וּ אֶל־יוֹסֵ֖ף לֵאמֹ֑ר אָבִ֣יךָ צִוָּ֔ה לִפְנֵ֥י מוֹת֖וֹ לֵאמֹֽר:
(יז)
כֹּֽה־תֹאמְר֣וּ לְיוֹסֵ֗ף אָ֣נָּ֡א שָׂ֣א נָ֠א פֶּ֣שַׁע אַחֶ֤יךָ וְחַטָּאתָם֙ כִּי־רָעָ֣ה גְמָל֔וּךָ וְעַתָּה֙ שָׂ֣א נָ֔א לְפֶ֥שַׁע עַבְדֵ֖י אֱלֹהֵ֣י אָבִ֑יךָ וַיֵּ֥בְךְּ יוֹסֵ֖ף בְּדַבְּרָ֥ם אֵלָֽיו:
(יח)
וַיֵּלְכוּ֙ גַּם־אֶחָ֔יו וַֽיִּפְּל֖וּ לְפָנָ֑יו וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ הִנֶּ֥נּֽוּ לְךָ֖ לַעֲבָדִֽים:
(יט)
וַיֹּ֧אמֶר אֲלֵהֶ֛ם יוֹסֵ֖ף אַל־תִּירָ֑אוּ כִּ֛י הֲתַ֥חַת אֱלֹהִ֖ים אָֽנִי:
(כ)
וְאַתֶּ֕ם חֲשַׁבְתֶּ֥ם עָלַ֖י רָעָ֑ה אֱלֹהִים֙ חֲשָׁבָ֣הּ לְטֹבָ֔ה לְמַ֗עַן עֲשֹׂ֛ה כַּיּ֥וֹם הַזֶּ֖ה לְהַחֲיֹ֥ת עַם־רָֽב:
(כא)
וְעַתָּה֙ אַל־תִּירָ֔אוּ אָנֹכִ֛י אֲכַלְכֵּ֥ל אֶתְכֶ֖ם וְאֶֽת־טַפְּכֶ֑ם וַיְנַחֵ֣ם אוֹתָ֔ם וַיְדַבֵּ֖ר עַל־לִבָּֽם:
Yosef returned to Egypt, he and his brothers
and all who had gone up with him to bury his father. When Yosef’s brothers saw
that their father had died, they said, “What if Yosef still bears a grudge
against us and pays us back for all the wrong that we did him!” So they sent
this message to Yosef, “Before his death your father left this instruction: So
shall you say to Yosef, ‘Forgive, I urge you, the offense and guilt of your
brothers who treated you so harshly.’ Therefore, please forgive the offense of
the servants of the God of your father.” And Yosef was in tears as they spoke
to him. His brothers went to him themselves, flung themselves before him, and
said, “We are prepared to be your slaves.” But Yosef said to them, “Have no
fear! Am I a substitute for God? Besides, although you intended me harm, God
intended it for good, so as to bring about the present result—the survival of
many people. And so, fear not. I will sustain you and your children.” Thus, he
reassured them, speaking kindly to them. (Bereishit 50:14-21)
Despite living as a reunited family for
seventeen years, the brothers were far from convinced that this was the true
Yosef. They were convinced that the détente achieved was only due to their
father’s presence. Now, with Yaakov dead and buried, Yosef would take his
“pound of flesh” and kill them all. Yosef for his part is shocked by their
mistrust, hurt by the knowledge that they could even suspect him of such
thoughts. He repeats the speech he had given when he first revealed his identity,
and again exonerates them, explaining that this was God’s will.
If Yosef’s goal was rapprochement, he
failed; if, however, his goal was to demonstrate his superiority, he was
successful.
Yosef remains a complex character. He
achieved dizzying power, unimaginable success. He created a system of social
welfare in the depths of the dark ages by applying the teachings of Avraham on
a national scale: Whereas Avraham opened his tent to tend to those in need, Yosef
anticipated and responded to the needs of an empire,[8] all the while
remaining true to the faith of Avraham, he had learned from his fathers, never
losing sight of the hand of God that made his accomplishments possible.
Is this split – in Yosef’s personality,
and between Yosef and his brothers – ever healed? The final chapter of Yosef’s
life story is one of true reconciliation:
בראשית פרק נ, כד-כו
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר יוֹסֵף֙ אֶל־אֶחָ֔יו אָנֹכִ֖י מֵ֑ת
וֵֽאלֹהִ֞ים פָּקֹ֧ד יִפְקֹ֣ד אֶתְכֶ֗ם וְהֶעֱלָ֤ה אֶתְכֶם֙ מִן־הָאָ֣רֶץ הַזֹּ֔את
אֶל־הָאָ֕רֶץ אֲשֶׁ֥ר נִשְׁבַּ֛ע לְאַבְרָהָ֥ם לְיִצְחָ֖ק וּֽלְיַעֲקֹֽב:
וַיַּשְׁבַּ֣ע יוֹסֵ֔ף אֶת־בְּנֵ֥י יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל לֵאמֹ֑ר פָּקֹ֨ד יִפְקֹ֤ד
אֱלֹהִים֙ אֶתְכֶ֔ם וְהַעֲלִתֶ֥ם אֶת־עַצְמֹתַ֖י מִזֶּֽה: וַיָּ֣מָת יוֹסֵ֔ף
בֶּן־מֵאָ֥ה וָעֶ֖שֶׂר שָׁנִ֑ים וַיַּחַנְט֣וּ אֹת֔וֹ וַיִּ֥ישֶׂם בָּאָר֖וֹן
בְּמִצְרָֽיִם:
Yosef
said to his brothers, “I am about to die. God will surely take notice of you
and bring you up from this land to the land that He promised on oath to Avraham,
to Yitzchak, and to Yaakov.” So Yosef made the sons of Israel swear, saying,
“When God has taken notice of you, you shall carry up my bones from here.”
Yosef died at the age of one hundred and ten years; and he was embalmed and placed
in a coffin in Egypt. (Bereishit 50:24-26)
On his deathbed, in his final words to
his brothers, Yosef begs them to promise that they will take his remains with
them when they leave Egypt; he longs to be a part of the family, and not a part
of the Egyptian pantheon. At last, there is peace - not only because the man
they fear is on death’s door, but because a real change has occurred. If we
listen carefully, as the brothers most certainly did, we hear a different Yosef.
Yosef finally understood what his father Yaakov had known before he came to
Egypt; this would not be a five-year visit to wait out the famine. This is not the
story of Yosef. This is the start of a long, difficult exile. Yosef’s dreams
are no longer the point; history has moved on. They are now all characters in
the dreams and visions of Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. The Children of Israel
– Yosef’s included, will be in Egypt for a very long time – but God will redeem
them, and when He does, Yosef wants to be a part of it. He wants to leave with
his brothers - the brothers who may never have loved him, who certainly never
displayed love for him; the brothers for whom he had cared for the past seventy
years.
Now, something has changed: Yosef, who had
always been so brash, so confident, was suddenly vulnerable. For the first time,
he needed them - not as pawns or marionettes in his show, but as brothers. When he
acknowledges that, their relationship changes: At last, they are equals. They
promise Yosef that they will see that his remains are returned home. And the
moment they make this vow, the family finally becomes whole. They are brothers
at last, equals, the founders of one nation.
Pharaoh would forget Yosef, but his
brothers, who finally felt like brothers, would never forget Yosef. And the
brothers who sold him into slavery would bring him back home, as brothers,
forever, at last.
Chazak chazak vnitchazek!
© Rabbi Ari Kahn
2017
[1]
Rashbam, Bereishit 48:8.
רשב"ם
בראשית פרשת ויחי פרק מח פסוק ח
וירא ישראל -
אעפ"י שכת' לפנינו (ו)לא יוכל לראות, יש רואה דמות אדם ואינו מכיר דמות פניו.
…
[2]
Malbim, Bereishit 48:8.
מלבי"ם
בראשית פרשת ויחי פרק מח פסוק ח
וירא ישראל.
מלבושי העברים היו משונים ממלבושי המצרים, ויוסף שהיה קרוב למלכות, וכן בניו היו
לובשים כמלבושי שרי מצרים, וכמ"ש של בית ר"ג היו משנים מהלכתן משום כבוד
מלכות, וע"כ תמה יעקב ואמר מי אלה, ויאמר יוסף בני הם, והם צדיקים ויראי ה',
ומה שאתה רואה אותם משונים במלבושיהם מפני אשר נתן לי אלהים בזה, שנולדו בזה המקום
והמקום והמצב מחייב זאת:
[3] The
text (Bereishit 37:3) stresses that Yisrael loved Yosef because he was a “ben
zekunim” which is understood by Rashi as a clever son. The name Yisrael, tends
to be used on a more national as opposed to personal level. This would indicate
that Yaakov/Yisrael thought that on objective terms he favored Yosef. Later in
the narrative, the brothers acknowledge that Yosef was loved by Yaakov.
[4]
Many debate the extent of fulfillment of the dreams, only ten and not eleven
bowed, a brother was missing, their father (and Yosef’s mother) were missing.
Nonetheless in terms of substance of the dreams, their sheaves bowing to his
sheaves, and the stars bowing to him – represent Yosef supplying food
specifically, and his power generally, these elements did come true.
[5]
Parashat Vayigash 5778 “Emotional
Truth: Becoming Brothers Once Again” http://arikahn.blogspot.co.il/2017/12/parashat-vayigash-5778-emotional-truth.html
[6] See
comments of Radak to Bereishit 46:34, Yosef did not want his brothers to
receive government positions. Presumably Paroh would adduce if having one
“Yosef” work for him changed the economy of Egypt – imagine what a team of
twelves “Yosefs” could do.
רד"ק בראשית פרשת ויגש פרק מו פסוק לד
(לד) בעבור תשבו
בארץ גשן - לפי שהיתה ארץ מקנה, ועוד כדי שלא יקח אתכם לעבודת המלך:
[7] See
my essay “Who Are These”: http://www.aish.com/tp/i/moha/48937092.html,
specifically note the Zohar cited which links the question of Yaakov: “Who are
these” mi eleh, with the declaration made when the Golden Calf in the
desert and the pair of golden calves by Yerovam were constructed and worshiped.
(“these are your gods Israel – eleh alohecha Yisrael).
זוהר
חלק א דף רכז/א
וַיַּרְא
יִשְׂרָאֵל אֶת בְּנֵי יוֹסֵף וַיֹּאמֶר מִי אֵלֶּה, אָמַר רִבִּי יִצְחָק, הַאי
קְרָא קַשְׁיָא, דִּכְתִיב וַיַּרְא יִשְׂרָאֵל, וּכְתִיב וְעֵינֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל
כָּבְדוּ מִזּוֹקֶן לֹא יוּכַל לִרְאוֹת, אִי לֹא יוּכַל לִרְאוֹת, מַהוּ וַיַּרְא
יִשְׂרָאֵל. אֶלָּא דְּחָמָא בְּרוּחַ קוּדְשָׁא, אִינוּן בְּנֵי יוֹסֵף,
דְּאִינוּן יָרָבְעָם וַחֲבֵירָיו. דְּיָרָבְעָם עֲבַד תְּרֵין עֶגְלֵי זָהָב,
וְאָמַר (מלכים א יב) אֵלֶּה אֱלֹהֶיךָ יִשְׂרָאֵל. וּבְגִין כָּךְ, מִי אֵלֶּה,
מַאן הוּא דְּזַמִּין לְמֵימַר אֵלֶּה אֱלֹהֶיךָ לְטַעֲוָון אָחֳרָן, וּבְגִין
כָּךְ וַיַּרְא יִשְׂרָאֵל אֶת בְּנֵי יוֹסֵף: מִכָּאן,
דְּצַדִּיקַיָיא חָמָאן עוֹבָדָא לְמֵרָחוֹק, וְקוּדְשָׁא בְּרִיךְ הוּא מְעַטֵּר
לוֹן בְּעִטְרָא דִילֵיהּ, מַה קוּדְשָׁא בְּרִיךְ הוּא חָמֵי לְמֵרָחוֹק, כְּמָה
דִכְתִיב, (בראשית א) וַיַּרְא אֱלֹהִים אֶת כָּל אֲשֶׁר עָשָׂה וְהִנֵּה טוֹב
מְאֹד, דְּקוּדְשָׁא בְּרִיךְ הוּא חָמָא כָּל עוֹבָדִין, עַד לָא יַעֲבֵד לוֹן,
וְכֻלְּהוּ אַעֲבָרוּ קַמֵּיהּ:
“And Israel saw the sons of Joseph,
and he said: "Who are these?" This verse seems
to contradict the statement a few verses later that "the eyes of Israel
were dim from age, so that he could not see". What this verse really
means, however, is that he saw through the Holy Spirit those later descendants
of Joseph, Jeroboam and his fraternity. Jeroboam made two golden calves and
said: These are thy gods, O Israel (1 Kings 12:28). Hence Israel now said, "Who are
these?" That is, "Who is he that will one day say these to idols?"
From this passage, we learn that the righteous see into the distant future and
God crowns them with His own crown.” (Zohar, Bereishit, 227b)
[8] See
Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik “Vision and Leadership – Reflection on Joseph and
Moses” Toras HoRav Foundation, Ktav 2013, page 28ff.
No comments:
Post a Comment